July 30, 2018

Soccer player undergoes two ACL surgeries

Knee | Patient Stories | Sports Injury

This article is part of the Ultimate Guide to Sports Medicine

For someone as active and competitive as 15-year-old Shanna Moffatt, a sports injury is just another obstacle to overcome. When she was just 13-years-old she tore her right anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) during a soccer game.

Luckily, Shanna’s mom Leigh Ann wasted no time in setting up an appointment with Dr. Michael Thieken, OrthoIndy sports medicine specialist. After an X-ray and MRI, Dr. Thieken determined that Shanna would need surgery if she wanted to return to sports.

ACL reconstruction surgery

Treatment for an ACL injury depends on the needs of the patient and the other injuries involved. Surgery is often necessary to return to sports and an active lifestyle; however, a less active individual may return to their lifestyle without surgery.

“From the moment I met Shanna, I knew she would do very well with our recommended treatment,” said Dr. Thieken. “She was knowledgeable about her diagnosis and treatment, motivated to return to full activity and extremely mature for her age. She underwent ACL reconstruction surgery and her post-operative course went as smoothly as one could expect.”

After Shanna’s recovery she put her injury behind her and even made the varsity soccer team when she was a freshman in high school. She also played basketball and ran frequently.

ACL and lateral meniscus tears

But this was just the beginning of Shanna’s experience with Dr. Thieken. Two years later, Shanna tore her left ACL and lateral meniscus in the first game of her sophomore varsity soccer season.

Shanna was devastated. “I couldn’t go running, which I love so much, I couldn’t pick up and carry little kids at church, I couldn’t walk for a month, I couldn’t wear heels to the homecoming dance and I couldn’t really dance either. I was very discouraged.”

Once again, Shanna made her way to Dr. Thieken’s clinic for a visit.

“After Shanna’s second injury on the opposite knee there was absolutely no question in our minds where we were taking her,” said Leigh Ann. “We wouldn’t take her anywhere else. Throughout all my medical experiences living here the past 30 years, OrthoIndy has been the most positive of all of them. We are truly grateful.”

ACL and meniscus reconstruction

It is common for ACL tears to be accompanied by other knee injuries such as a meniscus tear; however, this always means surgery is necessary to return to sports.

According to Dr. Thieken,“The anterior cruciate ligament is an extremely important ligament for stability of the knee during twisting and pivoting type motions. ACL reconstruction is a procedure done almost entirely arthroscopically in which we create a new ACL with either some of the patient’s tissue or cadaver tissue.”

“This new ACL graft is fixed in bone tunnels to allow graft to bone healing. With extensive physical therapy and time to allow the graft to mature, an individual can return to the sports and other activities that they love,” said Dr. Thieken.

Recovery, physical therapy and a return to sports

Shanna’s surgery was successful and she started on the road to recovery. For all patients who choose ACL surgery, physical therapy is very important. It focuses on reducing swelling and pain while returning motion to the joint and surrounding muscles. Complete rehabilitation is vital before making a full return to sports or a repeat injury can occur.

“From the moment we walked through OrthoIndy’s doors and were greeted at the front desk to the moment we left, everyone who dealt with us all made us feel like we were the only ones in the hospital that day,” said Leigh Ann.

Shanna was able to train with the track team in the spring until she was fully cleared by Dr. Theiken to compete. In May she was able to run in the final two track meets.  She didn’t win those races, but she was excited that she didn’t come in last, even wearing a knee brace.  She began workouts with her soccer team in June and looks forward to her junior year.

“My experience at OrthoIndy was amazing. I always felt comfortable and taken care of. Everyone was so nice and made sure I had everything I needed. Through this whole journey of two injuries, Dr. Thieken has encouraged me, and he is the reason I’m back doing the things I love,” said Shanna. “I know I have had the best care possible over the last two years of my life.”

To schedule an appointment with Dr. Thieken please call 317.802.2863, go to his website or learn more about sports medicine treatment at OrthoIndy.

Schedule an appointment

Your well-being is important to us. Click the button below or call us to schedule an appointment with one of our orthopedic specialists. If your injury or condition is recent, you can walk right into one of our OrthoIndy Urgent Care locations for immediate care. For rehabilitation and physical therapy, no referral is needed to see one of our physical therapists.

Schedule an Appointment Call OrthoIndy 317.802.2000
Megan Golden

By Megan Golden

Megan Golden worked at OrthoIndy from 2012 to 2019, where she wrote a variety of content for our blog, magazines and inbound campaigns. Megan graduated from Ball State University in 2012 with a bachelor’s degree in public relations and advertising and communications studies minor.

Related Posts

More from OrthoIndy

What is subacromial impingement syndrome?

What is subacromial impingement syndrome?

Repeated overhead motion can cause inflammation in your rotator cuff, making the tendons swell and “catch” on your upper shoulder bone. This is called subacromial impingement syndrome.


Why do they call it Tommy John Surgery?

Why do they call it Tommy John Surgery?

Tommy John is a retired pitcher who played Major League Baseball from 1963 to 1989. If your team’s baseball pitcher needs Tommy John Surgery, it usually means overuse caused the UCL to fray, tear or become loose.


6 tips to stay positive after surgery in the summer

6 tips to stay positive after surgery in the summer

Recovering in the warmer months can be easier on your mental health than in the winter. Dr. Shook discusses how to safely take care of yourself, benefits of being outside and tips to stay positive after surgery in the warmer months.


Get stories and News in your inbox

Subscribe to our weekly articles