OrthoIndy is proud to share that 56 of our physicians have been named 2025 Top Doctors by Indianapolis Monthly. This recognition spans the full spectrum of orthopedic care, underscoring the trust and respect our doctors have earned among their peers across the Indianapolis medical community.
Each year, Indianapolis Monthly partners with Castle Connolly to conduct an extensive peer-review survey. Physicians in the area are asked to cast their votes based on who they would trust with their own care or recommend to a friend or family member.
The result is a carefully vetted list of doctors who consistently set the standard for clinical excellence.
“We are proud to see so many of our physicians recognized by their peers as leaders in orthopedic care,” said Dr. Matthew Lavery, president of OrthoIndy. “This recognition reflects not only the skill and dedication of our doctors but also the teams who support them each day. At OrthoIndy, our mission is to help patients return to the activities they love most, and it is rewarding to see our commitment to outstanding outcomes honored in this way.”
With more than 100 physicians, OrthoIndy provides personalized, leading-edge bone, joint, spine and muscle care at 21 convenient clinic locations, including five with orthopedic urgent care services. Click on the names of our honored physicians below to learn more or schedule an appointment.
The full 2025 Top Doctors feature is included in the November issue of Indianapolis Monthly, available in print and online at indianapolismonthly.com.
OrthoIndy’s 2025 Top Doctors
Anesthesiology
Foot & Ankle Surgery
Hand Surgery
- Robert Baltera, MD
- Nicholas Crosby, MD
- Roberty Falender, MD
- Jeffrey Greenberg, MD, MS
- Reed Hoyer, MD
- F. Thomas Kaplan, MD
- Christy Kellams, MD
- Greg Merrell, MD
- Kathryn Peck, MD
- Sameer Puri, MD
- Gregory Reveal, MD
- Gregory Schmidt, MD
- Rashad Usmani, MD
- Andrew Vicar, MD
- Matthew Walker, MD
Internal Medicine
Orthopedic Surgery
- Chris Bales, MD
- Renn Crichlow, MD
- Michael Cross, MD
- Gregory Dikos, MD
- Philip Huang, DO
- Timothy Hupfer, MD
- Kosmas Kayes, MD
- Matthew Lavery, MD
- M. Craig McMains, MD
- Patrick Millikan, MD
- Eric Monesmith, MD
- David Myer, MD
- Kevin O’Neill, MD
- Greg Poulter, MD
- Gregory Reveal, MD
- Troy Roberson, MD
- Stephen Shively, DO
- Jonathan Shook, MD
- Michael Thieken, MD
- Rashad Usmani, MD
- George Vestermark, MD
- Peter Wasky, MD
Pain Medicine
Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation
- Virgilio Chan, MD
- Ryan Dill, MD
- Vince Hume, DO
- Ronald Miller, MD
- Mark Osborne, MD
- Richard Rosales, MD, MBA
- Kevin Sigua, MD
- Seung Sim, MD
Spine Surgery
- John Dietz Jr., MD
- Robert Huler, MD
- Gabriel Jackson, MD
- M. Craig McMains, MD
- Kevin O’Neill, MD
- Greg Poulter, MD
- David Schwartz, MD
Sports Medicine
