The honorees represent eight specialties spanning the full spectrum of orthopedic care, including nonsurgical treatment, rehabilitation and surgery.
INDIANAPOLIS — OrthoIndy is proud to share that 52 physicians have been recognized by their peers with 62 Indianapolis Monthly Top Doctor honors for 2026. The recognition spans the full spectrum of orthopedic care and reflects the expertise of physicians serving patients across Central Indiana.
“We’re proud to see so many physicians from OrthoIndy and Indiana Hand to Shoulder Center, an OrthoIndy practice, recognized by their peers as leaders in orthopedic care,” said Dr. Matthew Lavery, president and CEO of OrthoIndy and recipient of two 2026 Top Doc honors. “Whether it’s their first recognition or one of many, it’s especially meaningful because it reflects the trust of fellow physicians. We’re grateful for the opportunity to bring that same level of expertise and commitment to the patients and families we serve every day.”
Each year, Indianapolis Monthly partners with Castle Connolly to identify the area’s Top Docs through an extensive peer-review process. Physicians are asked to nominate doctors they would trust with their own care or recommend to a friend or family member.
The result is a carefully vetted list recognizing physicians who consistently demonstrate excellence in their specialties.
OrthoIndy’s 2026 Top Docs practice at locations throughout Central Indiana, including OrthoIndy at Ascension St. Vincent Carmel, OrthoIndy at Ascension St. Vincent Indianapolis, OrthoIndy Brownsburg, OrthoIndy Center Grove, OrthoIndy Fishers, OrthoIndy Greenwood, OrthoIndy at Hancock Health, Indiana Hand to Shoulder Center – an OrthoIndy practice, OrthoIndy Northwest and the OrthoIndy Northwest Pre-Operative Clinic.
Click on the names of our honored physicians below to learn more or schedule an appointment.
The full 2026 Top Docs feature is included in the November issue of Indianapolis Monthly, available in print and online at indianapolismonthly.com.
OrthoIndy’s Top Docs for 2026
Anesthesiology
Foot & Ankle Surgery
Hand Surgery
- Ian Chow, MD
- Nicholas Crosby, MD
- Robert Falender, MD
- Reed Hoyer, MD, FAAOS
- F. Thomas Kaplan, MD, FAAOS
- Christy Kellams, MD
- Greg Merrell, MD
- Kathryn Peck, MD
- Sameer Puri, MD
- Gregory Reveal, MD
- Gregory Schmidt, MD
- Brandon Smetana, MD, FAAOS
- Rashad Usmani, MD
- Matthew Walker, MD
Internal Medicine
Orthopedic Surgery
- Chris Bales, MD
- Mitchell Beckert, MD
- Renn Crichlow, MD
- Michael Cross, MD
- Gregory Dikos, MD
- Andrew Gudeman, MD
- Philip Huang, DO
- Matthew Lavery, MD
- M. Craig McMains, MD, FAAOS
- Patrick Millikan, MD
- Eric Monesmith, MD
- David Myer, MD
- Kevin O’Neill, MD
- Greg Poulter, MD
- Gregory Reveal, MD
- Troy Roberson, MD
- Abhi Seetharam, MD
- Stephen Shively, DO
- Jonathan Shook, MD
- Michael Thieken, MD
- Rashad Usmani, MD
- George Vestermark, MD
- Peter Wasky, MD
Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation
- Virgilio Chan, MD
- Ryan Dill, MD
- Vince Hume, DO
- Ronald Miller, MD
- Mark Osborne, MD
- Richard Rosales, MD, MBA
- Kevin Sigua, MD
Spine Surgery
- John Dietz Jr., MD
- Gabriel Jackson, MD
- M. Craig McMains, MD, FAAOS
- Kevin O’Neill, MD
- Greg Poulter, MD
- David Schwartz, MD
Sports Medicine